Red Pepper News: Privatisation? What us?

18 March 2006

Privatisation? What us?

The blue pearl necklace fell out of the corporate press pack like an unwanted christmas cracker toy. It was accompanied by a new-age sounding insert that explained that the necklace "represented the transparency and fragility of water, a crucial resource that needs our constant care."

The media pack was embossed with glossy photos of water works across the world and talked of dignity, tolerance, rights, progress and transparency.

Clearly the Fourth World Water Forum in Mexico which has been condemned by activists as a front for promoting worldwide water privatisation is seeking an image change.

In fact the one word you won't hear very often is "privatisation" in the World Water Forum. Instead it's all talk about plurality, different models of water management, learning from each other.

Speaking in an opening press conference, Jose Luis Luege Tamargo, Secretary for the Environment and Natural Resources Ministry of Mexico said: "No-one is trying to impose privatisation here. This forum is about debate and dialogue about the solutions."

To his right, Loic Fauchon the head of the World Water Council and head of a Marseilles-based subsidiary of the water multinational Suez nodded his head vigorously. Bizarrely during his speech, he had said: "At risk of angering people, we must say that mobile phones which we all have are good but drinking water is even better." Well glad that he has at least worked that one out...

Of course the change in language is a result of strong campaigning by global water activists who, through speaking out about the effects of water privatisation, have rightly given it a bad name. In the last World Water Forum in Kyoto in 2003, the proceedings were frequently disrupted by activists denouncing the pro-privatisation agenda of the meetings and saying water was a fundamental human right that shouldn't be governed by greed.

On the ground in various cities, companies like Suez have been thrown out by huge rebellions. In Bolivia US multinational giant Bechtel was thrown out of Cochabamba and Suez is in the process of being expelled from El Alto after both companies put prices up to unaffordable levels and tried to take control of communal water supplies. In France, Grenoble threw out its private water utility and then installed a municipal water authority with citizen involvement that now boasts some of the highest quality water and cheapest water rates in France.

Increasingly even pro-private sector advocates are admitting that privatisation of a basic resource like water doesn't work in poor countries. They find it hard to refute the argument made by Pablo Solón one of the advisors to the Bolivian Ministry of Water who says: "You can't make money from water in poor countries so companies only operate in districts which are profitable which leaves thousands without water."

Unfortunately that message still hasn't quite got home to institutions like the World Bank. Soon after Evo Morales was elected, the World Bank came to Bolivia filling the news papers with soundbites about how great it was to be working with a Government that shared the World Bank's vision of a "world free of poverty" and saying they recognised the huge democratic mandate the Bolivian Government had.

Yet in the first meeting with the Bolivian Ministry of Water, the World Bank categorically refused to fund a public water utility in El Alto, saying it would only fund it after two years of proving it worked. They remained impervious to any arguments such as the fact that 80% of the world's water services are run by public utilities, the complete failure of privatisation to work in El Alto, and the Government's practical proposals to produce a far more efficient and transparent utility than the private one.

There may be new people at the table in Bolivia, but for the World Bank the menu stays firmly the same.

It's also a menu that still firmly remains the ideological objective of many in the World Water Forum. Despite attempts to hide behind different rhetoric, it has taken surprisingly little time for people with considerable power to show their true agenda. In fact Jose Luis Luege, Mexico's environment secretary who said that the World Water Forum wasn't pushing water privatisation at the same time said he supported the idea of granting concessions for specific water projects to private firms. Giving projects to private companies apparently isn't privatisation.

A press release sent out by the World Water Forum still brazenly said that "Private participation is considered positive as regards water supply and sanitation in tourist areas (Mexico, Cuba and Uruguay) and for the treatment of wastewater (Mexico, Brazil, Colombia); in cities of Bolivia (La Paz, El Alto, Cochabamba), Brazil (JundiaÃ, Limeira and Manaus)..." They could well have used a list of all the cities and regions that have seen the biggest protests in Latin America against water privatisation. You would find yourself hard-pressed to find any people in El Alto or Cochabamba who view water privatisation as "positive."

I also talked in one meeting to Bill Turner who said he ran projects for the US aid department, yet also runs a business, Waterbank, that "trades in water rights" and "facilitates privatisation of water systems" and claims to "bear powerful, behind the scenes, political influence to further transactions when necessary."

He unashamedly referred to water as a commodity, claiming that one of his projects to export water from Canada to California was being pointlessly blocked because otherwise "the river would be going to waste." Realising the extremeness of his comments, he retracted slightly but his agenda was frighteningly clear. In his world, it won't be long before there is "airbank" after all think of all that air going to waste that we don't use to breathe.

In many ways, water could be the apogee of a politics of liberalisation and privatisation, because movements of water activists have not just mobilised and raised consciousness and outrage at the thought of privatising a basic human need, but have succeeded in reversing specific privatisations. However it's clear that in the World Water Forum, that many in power have changed language but little of their ideology. No amount of trinkets should persuade us otherwise.

18 March 2006 in Corporations | Permalink

Comments

Posted by: Gregory | 01 June 2007 at 04:04 PM

Posted by: Gregory | 01 June 2007 at 04:05 PM

Posted by: Hairston | 23 June 2007 at 09:06 PM

[u][b] GENERIC VIAGRA: 60 pills x 50mg = $111 (Save $70), 60 pills x 100mg = $141 (Save $66) [/b][/u]
[url=http://www.drugsmarket.medsjoy.biz]purchase VIAGRA[/url] - VIAGRA woman

[u][b] Achetez VIAGRA le plus bon marchй cialis [/b][/u]
[url=http://www.acheterviagra.medsjoy.biz/Viagra.htm]achetez VIAGRA generique[/url] - VIAGRA alternatif
[u][b] Kaufen Sie preiswerten VIAGRA online [/b][/u]
[url=http://www.viagrakaufen.enjoymeds.biz/Viagra.htm]VIAGRA-Frau[/url] - kaufen Sie online VIAGRA

[u][b] Pida a Medicamento sin marca Barato VIAGRA Cialis en Lнnea [/b][/u]
[url=http://www.comprarviagra.medsjoy.biz/Viagra.htm]compre VIAGRA en linea[/url] - compra VIAGRA

Posted by: joanasevilyboaz | 08 November 2007 at 12:45 AM

Good day , i have spend many days trying to find so informative site like your redpepper.blogs.com !
Great thanks!
I'am sure i will stay here for many hours now! :)

Posted by: AaAZeeeeeD | 04 January 2008 at 11:44 PM

http://www.casinosonlinecasinos.org/ is the best online casino and only here you could enjoy the most higher casino bonuses and promotions from the internet. Online casino games are very funny but can be a big pain if you get to borrow money for it. Online casino functions with computer software programs and jurisdiction licenses. Here you can play as long as you want your favorite casino gambling games without loosing anything.

Posted by: Monik | 15 February 2008 at 09:36 PM

At http://www.casino-slot-machine.net you will find the best Casino Slot Machine Games with no download required, but also you should know that it's your choice if you want to play for money or for free, because the most trusted casinos always want to satisfy their clients, so besides so many odds and gambling promotions they also learn you, to play slots machine games and all the rules and game tricks so that your chances to win will be maximum. Today’s gamblers may use their credit cards to play for real money their most loved games and can get participation in any kind of online gambling events, so they may choose anything they want. There is no more any need to travel in different places of the world searching of casinos! Nowadays online gambling gives an opportunity to all gamblers from the world.

Posted by: Andrei | 18 February 2008 at 10:34 AM

Play the game for yourself, discover all the cool features we couldn't fit into a description and find the newest free slots informations and the most trusted free slots online, study all gambling rules and find out all the necessary tips and strategies which can help you to win money. The latest slots to be released and the releases you may have missed.
Play at http://www.freeonline-slots.net for free and if you want to know how to win at Slots, learn about the various slot machine strategies, play free online Slots or play for real-money and receive higher bonus codes and play for free or register as a real player and play for cash. Play free slots games and you will became the best you can play for real money. Test your luck before gambling for real money. Get ready for a real gambling experience and you'll be glad you stopped by!

Posted by: Jack | 18 February 2008 at 10:42 AM

Play at the best free online casinos and you could enjoy the most higher casino bonuses and gambling promotions from the internet. http://www.freeonline-casinos.net have a great number of interesting and exciting free casino games and they also offer huge bonuses too. Free online casino functions with computer software programs and jurisdiction licenses. Here you can play as long as you want your favorite casino gambling games without loosing anything.
The competition between all free online casinos is really huge, but http://www.free-onlinecasinos.org is one of the most trusted and rated from all casino directories and they also have great promotions and odds. Online casino games are free and just play for fun. They work on these casino games as a labor of love, with the hopes that people will find it useful, and in turn share it with their own friends and family.

Posted by: M. | 19 February 2008 at 03:09 PM

Ladies and Gentlemen,
My name is Jaime Pressly , this is my first
post. I didn't find relevant
thread to post this, and I apologize in advance, if I posted inappropriately,
please advise.
Early last year, I discovered information about
investment funds, that are not readily available to the public. The earnings, which investors could
receive by investing in such
programs, looked
surprisingly high at
first, but as I investigated more feedbacks about them, I started to
invest. Guess what, today, I consider
myself to become the successful
player. To take my online adventures on the next level, I
set up the blog, which
shows detailed information
about current investment funds. You can see my
blog, [url=HTTP://WWW.16DAILYHYIP.COM]follow this URL[/url]. I would would be glad to receive
your comments.

Posted by: Investblogger | 27 February 2008 at 01:04 PM

During selection I have sorted out a dozen of the offers, which have seemed to me perspective.

Then has stopped on the sole company, which really guarantees safety of the contributions -
The Stoic. Already 6 months I work with it .
The charge on percents go permanently

Working with The Stoic you can receive on yours deposit up to 3 percentsDAILY!

If you are interested in this information, there is my referral link.

http://www.stoic-capital.com/index.php?partner=7346029537

Having registered with it you receive from me half of referral commission from yours deposit.
For details write to PM
The Stoic - The Real Online Investment.
Also you can to acquaint with monitoring of this company on the largest resource about online investments

http://www.hyip.com/hyip/common/2572/The+Stoic

Posted by: sttrqiss | 07 April 2008 at 04:21 AM

My name is James

Hi everyone. I am new to this forum. I would just like to say that I am glad I found it, and I look forward to
becoming a productive member in this community.

----------------------
[url=http://offto.net/500]Work From Home[/url]

Posted by: Hiemearliah | 12 November 2008 at 02:17 PM

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

Posted by: |

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:

Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Red Pepper News

18 March 2006

Privatisation? What us?

Comments

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

Post a comment

December 2006

Categories

Recent Posts

Archives

Red Pepper

Radical Blogs

TNI News

Sun	Mon	Tue	Wed	Thu	Fri	Sat
					1	2
3	4	5	6	7	8	9
10	11	12	13	14	15	16
17	18	19	20	21	22	23
24	25	26	27	28	29	30
31